- 74,587
- 62,244
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2004
Good argument and it does seem like the Mustang is a better buy and it probably is but BMW offers luxury and luxury isn't suppose to be a logical purchase.Originally Posted by methedy23
- Where do I start?!!?
- BMW should be ashamed; both of these cars primary selling point is phenomenal performance, and both deliver. However, the Mustang is essentially (objectively speaking) the performance
equal of the M3 for basically 1/2 the price. I understand that the M3 handles better, but not 30K better; and the new Mustangs' handling/ characteristics /balance is vastly improved compared to the previous gen (2005-2009)
- The M3's interior is nice/adequate, but the M3 is clearly not selling interior refinement as the largest notch in its belt. You can get the same interior for basically half the price in a lower model 3-series or something from Acura, Lexus, etc. The point being that the interior does not make up that 30K price gap. If you're selling performance at twice the price, you need to dominate all categories, clearly...and that is just not the case here.
- Reliability???! If you look at an objective source, Consumer Reports (about as objective as you're going to get; considering that their data is obtained from the subscriber base...You and I) they have been ranking the American's above the German's in terms of reliability for years now...Category: Problems per 1000 vehicles
- In conclusion: I love both of these cars, but when your compare both head-to-head, something is clearly insufficient. The Mustang appears to be a statistical bargain, while the M3 appears to take advantage of your finances/sensibilities. I can buy that Mustang, a sick 'cycle and put a nice down payment on a house instead of simply buying the M3; assuming both are being purchased in full upon inception.
- And if status is the issue, there's always the Shelby GT500, which is more comparable to the M3 in terms of price and certain to turn many heads. Value/Performance/Style/Reliability/Reputation/Comfort/Interior/Overall Refinement/Cost to Own/Resale/etc. Many factors to consider. This was fun to discuss.
Like I said earlier, for a comparable price, I'd take the 335i over the Mustang with 100 less hp and chances are it will still be more fun to drive for me.
Plus Mustangs and most American cars selling point is their pricebeing much lower.
If Ford can sell the Mustang for comparable price to the M3 and most people actually buy it, I am pretty sure they would.
